Begin van de serie. Onder druk van de gemeenschap geeft rechercheur Mare Sheehan opdracht om een onopgeloste verdwijningszaak weer op te pakken.
Gastrollen:
Cameron Mann(Ryan Ross), Patrick Murney(Kenny McMenamin), Patsy Meck(Jan Kelly), Kate Arrington(Faye), Ruby Cruz(Jess Riley), Pat DeFusco(Officer Tommy Boyle), Justin Hurtt-Dunkley(Officer Trammel), Mackenzie Lansing(Brianna Delrasso), Kittson O'Neill(Officer Susie Holbert), Cody Kostro(Kevin Sheehan), Drew Scheid(Geoff Gabeheart), J. Paul Nicholas(Store Owner), Suli Holum(Stacey Woodley), Katie Kreisler(Trisha Riley), Jim Scopeletis(Dennis), Enid Graham(Dawn Bailey), Jack Mulhern(Dylan Hinchey), Chinasa Ogbuagu(Beth Hanlon), Phyllis Somerville(Betty Carroll), Madeline Weinstein(Becca Lynch), Izzy King(Drew Sheehan), Dominique Johnson(Freddie Hanlon), Patrick McDade(Glen Carroll), Brian Gallagher(Corporal Jimmy Masterson), Sadat Waddy(Sean), Rose Decker(Kenzie), Brian Rock(Katie's Uncle), Anthony Norman(Nathan Forde), Anthony Rugnetta(Bartender), Connie Giordano(Patty Delrasso), Kassie Mundhenk(Moira Ross), Hannah Flannery(Shannon), David E. Goodman(Athletic Director), Caroline Mixon(Kerry), Meredith Sullivan(Kylie), Rachel Poletick(Kelly), Gabi Faye(Brianna's Friend)