Terwijl Jeff op zijn proces wacht, behandelt zijn vader zijn eigen demonen, probeert de politie van Milwaukee zijn gezicht te redden en delen de families van de slachtoffers hun verhalen.
Gastrollen:
Karen Malina White(Shirley Hughes), David Barrera(Chief Arreola), Shaun Brown(Tracy Edwards), Colby French(Patrick Kennedy), Matthew Alan(Officer Gabrish), Scott Michael Morgan(Officer Balcerzak), Michael Beach(Det. Dennis Murphy), Penelope Ann Miller(Self - Joyce Dahmer), Khetphet Phagnasay(Southone Sinthasomphone), Phet Mahathongdy(Somdy Sinthasomphone), Dyllon Burnside(Ronald Flowers), Nikea Gamby-Turner(Mildred Lindsey), DaShawn Barnes(Rita Isbell), Nigel Gibbs(Reverend Jesse Jackson), Maurice Demus(Jacob), Amy Mack(Barbara Hughes), Rodney J. Hobbs(African American Sergeant), Clark Moore(Deputy Chief), Keyla McNeely(Dorothy Straughter), Kyrsten V. Williams(Kim Hughes), Tony Robinette(Donald Bradehoft), Jim McCaffree(Sheriff - 1957), Ava Ticotin(Janie Hagen), Scott Paophavihanh(Anouke Sinthasomphone), Dia Laren Nash(Sandra Smith), Brayden Maniago(Somsack Sinthasomphone), Corey Timmons(Will Hughes), Rosemary Thomas(Catherine Straughter), Spencer Squire(Nick), Michael Adler(Judge Lawrence Gram), Carlos Arellano(Bailiff), Molly Baker(Audience Member), Serene Branson(News Correspondent), Demi Castro(Geraldo Rivera), Chase Fein(Police Officer #2), Arye Gross(Gerald Boyle), Bobbie Lee Jr.(J.W. Smith), Ericka Kreutz(Female Sergeant), Mercy Malick(Milwaukee Reporter #2), Danny Max(Fresno Reporter #3), Markina Brown(Fresno Reporter #2), Vanessa Giordano(Fresno Reporter #1), Horace Gold(Isaac Richards), Shane Kerwin(Ed Gein), Ed Mattiuzzi(Milwaukee Reporter #3)